Saturday, April 9, 2022

Post 11: Christensen Chapter 3

 

Teaching for Joy

Teaching for Justice


This week’s reading was from chapter 3 of Teaching for Joy and Justice by Linda Christensen. In this chapter, Christensen details various ways to make, what her students call, a ‘fire’ essay. This kind of essay is one where the students are highly self-motivated to continuously draft and revise a piece of writing. Although it is not possible to make every writing assignment ‘fire,’ appropriately preparing students to tackle essay writing will improve their writing skills and turn them into ‘fire’ writers. However, the preparation that Christensen suggests is not the teaching of the traditional 5 paragraph essay. Instead, Christen tells readers that preparation for the “essay starts on the first day of any curriculum project” (121). This is done through various techniques in which students retrieve and collect “information from reading, media, and discussions” (121). Enriching a unit with a collection of materials that students can go back to for future reference on their essays is an incredibly smart way to teach essay writing. This method also saves a lot of time in the classroom, because students already did a sizable portion of the evidence finding as they read.

This is what happened when I read one of my blogs out loud


For the most part, Christensen covers the same ground as the classical five paragraph essay that I am familiar with from my time in the public school system. I enjoy that she takes a Critical approach to analytical writing when she states: “’Look, you can use incidents from your own life as evidence as well. If you had experiences with language that this unit tapped into, put those in the paper’” (124). By allowing students to incorporate a piece of oneself in their paper, Christensen sets the stage for them to examine ways in which their power, class, or race could be related to the unit or curriculum. I think that this is a great way to incorporate culturally responsive pedagogical practices into a writing style that is traditionally very formal and academic. 

However, I did not find myself agreeing with some of the advice present in the chapter. Namely the advice that “the thesis statement […] can be stated explicitly or implicitly” (125). In writing an essay, I am of the opinion that the thesis statement should always be explicitly stated at the end of the first paragraph especially if it is an analysis essay. One reason being that, as a reader of a student’s work, I would assume that no thesis was written. The other reason being that a reader may misinterpret an implicit thesis into meaning something that was not intended by the author in way that may be unintentionally positive or negative.



In my placement at Central Falls High School, I have yet to see any essay writing as of now. However, what I have seen are retrieval and collection strategies on display in one English class. This particular class is reading the book Born a Crime by Trevor Noah. Every day when class starts, the teacher will have a few short response prompts on the board that students have to answer either in class or for homework. This serves two purposes. First, it shows the teacher that students are engaging with the book. Second, the completion of these prompts will prove to be a useful resource in the future as they will be writing an essay about the book all on their own with no prompt from the teacher. This is a great real-life example of one of Christensen’s strategies being used.

Sunday, April 3, 2022

Post 10: Queering the Curriculum

Queer inventions

 The article that I chose to read this week is called “Rethinking Sexism, Gender, and Sexuality.” The author, Jodie Sokolower, delves into the modern understandings of the difference between sex, gender, and sexuality and how these issues are important to explore in the classroom. Sokolower then links these aspects to a litany of other issues like Black Lives Matter and LGBTQ struggles when she writes: 

“the Black Lives Matter movement is erupting in city after city. […] The urgency of that movement reinforces our conviction that LGBTQ struggles cannot be separated from the fabric of all struggles for social justice. Making schools safe for LGBTQ students, staff, and families is inextricable interwoven with the fight against racism” (12-13). 

I am confused by the link between LGBTQ rights and racism. The way that Sokolower delivers this statement makes me think that she means all issues concerning social justice are interconnected in some intersectional school of thought. I think back to the big green book of social justice that everyone in the school of education is given and how it contains a multipage chart illustrating how everything is intersectional. It is all very complicated and very loosely connected. I wonder what I am supposed to gain from all of this knowledge and what I should be conveying to students so that they can learn something from these social issues.

One aspect of the article is focused on how teachers can build and support LGBTQ students and colleagues by taking “approaches that open up discussions of LGBTQ rights and homophobia” in the classroom (23). When I read this, I tried to think of ways that I was already comfortable with supporting LGBTQ students and colleagues. One way that I already support LGBTQ students is through the classic golden rule. One way that I see LGBTQ students supported in my placement is through signs on the wall that show whether they be the rainbow flag or some variation thereof. This shows that the school supports LGBTQ students and is working to create a safe space for them. However, I do not think that this is enough. In classrooms, I still hear students use the word “gay” in a negative way and no one corrects them when this happens. There have also not been any readings in the class have had queer voices in them. Are the signs placed on the walls are really just lip service? Until I see these issues corrected, I will believe that to be the case, as so much more could be done to make the school inclusive.  


Friday, April 1, 2022

Post 9: High Quality Curriculum Hack Jam


This past week I attended an online meeting of the RIWP Spring Conference called the “High Quality Curriculum Hack Jam.” The meeting delved into how schools in Rhode Island are now using what is called a scripted curriculum. As someone who is a teaching hopeful, I was not informed what this type of curriculum was. I have only heard the phrase in passing and it was always followed by a negative remark about the quality of said curriculum. One teacher even told me that “Scripted curriculum makes my job so easy a monkey could do it!” To which I replied: “Finally, a curriculum for the rest of us!”


This event did not explain what a scripted curriculum was and why a school district would choose to use it or not. So, I went searched the term on the internet and concluded that this type of curriculum is sold by education companies to school districts. Sounds normal to me, but then what does ‘scripted’ mean? Well, it simply means that the teacher is given a script, like an actor, to read from while teaching a lesson. From what I could gather, a scripted curriculum is not viewed as a positive inclusion in the classroom because the teacher no longer has any input in the lesson planning process. As for how Critical these learning materials are I can safely say that there would be no room for incorporating culturally responsive or culturally sustaining pedagogy in these materials because it is impossible to pre-plan lessons that take students’ cultures into account. Each group of students is different from the next and this type of curriculum assumes that all students are the same and that all students are just learning receptacles.  




Fieldwork

Next week at Central Falls High School, I will be teaching my first lesson in front of a live studio audience. The lesson is an introduction to the Harlem Renaissance and will be focused on providing students background information about what the culture was like during that time period before moving on the next lesson where they will delve into key authors. I hope the students are receptive to the lesson as Marina and I work to make it engaging for them.

During my time at this school, I notice that the students don’t take kindly to asking for help. Every time the students start doing any sort of writing or groupwork I wander around the room asking students if they need assistance. All of them, all of the time, will tell me that they don’t need any help. This frustrates me because I see them holding their heads in their hands looking at a blank sheet of paper, and they refuse to ask for help! I usually ask a follow-up question in an effort to get to know them better when this happens like, “Do you enjoy this book? What’s your favorite part so far? Why?” And to my surprise, they will tell me that they either have not read the book, or they will just say “it’s good.”  I find this group of students to be very quiet. I think it is the result of the distance learning from the past few years.

Saturday, March 19, 2022

Post 8: En Comunidad Chapter 6 and Fieldwork

 

The face students make when you tell them you are beginning a poetry unit 


En Comunidad, chapter 6 by Carla Espana

In this book aimed at reaching the hearts and minds of multilingual Latino students, Carla Espana writes how teachers can use poetry to facilitate culturally sustaining pedagogy practices in the classroom. This text takes a Critical, antiracist approach to education by endorsing the use of culturally sustaining pedagogy, an educational practice that is about keeping the students’ home culture alive and present within the classroom. Espana accomplishes this through her month long “Bilingual Spanish-English Poetry Shared Reading Plan” (143). In this carefully curated list of poetry, the author considers her students’ cultural backgrounds and linguistic abilities. Elsewhere in the chapter, Espana writes: “A lot of wrongs have been done to and continue to be done to bilingual Latinx students. Reading poetry that shares these wrongs and how poets react to injustices helps children process” (139). By acknowledging that injustice that Latino students face the author invokes Muhammad’s Criticality as she is thinking “in ways of understanding power, privilege, social justice and oppression” and passing this information through poetry to her students.

The mystery of Lainx


One question I have about the text is the use of the word “Latinx” instead of “Latino”. I am confused about the word. In Spanish there are masculine and feminine verb endings and masculine nouns are used to refer to groups of people if there is at least one male in the mix, while a feminine word ending (‘a’) is only used when a group is all female. Because of the gendered verb endings, I think that the “x” is supposed to be gender neutral. But isn’t Latino already gender neutral because it includes both male and female? Also, how is Latinx pronounced? I wonder if this is related to the Chicana feminism that was mentioned in last week’s reading.




Fieldwork

I forgot to mention last week that I was able to sit in on Mr. Lemon’s ESL class on Monday at Central Falls High School! I was very excited to see this because I just started the TESOL program at RIC and was curious to see what an actual classroom could look like. I entered the room and there were about 13 students total. Mr. Lemon had everyone get into a circle and passed around a copy of the story that students were working their way through. He gave Marina and me a copy so we could follow along. The book was a biography of Cesar Chavez, aptly titled Cesar Chavez. Mr. Lemon was a textbook example of all the translanguaging strategies that I learned about in my TESOL class with Dr. Hesson at RIC. Mr. Lemon would repeat his instructions in both Spanish and English, provided copies of the text in both languages and used a reading guide.  




If Mr. Lemon provided a copy of this text in both English and Spanish, does that mean his Spanish speaking students are unable to read proficiently in their own language? After class ended, I stayed and chatted with Mr. Lemon for a bit. He informed me that some of his students did not have any education in their home countries before coming to the United States, which explains for the low reading level of text that was chosen. The students were about sixteen to seventeen years old, and they do not have much time in high school left. What if they don’t learn enough English by the time they graduate or age out of high school? What are they supposed to do after high school? How are these students supposed to enter the adult world and get a job, rent/buy property, and maybe go to college?

Sunday, March 13, 2022

Post 7: Borders and Fieldwork


Sin Fronteras

Writing Poetry About Borderlands to Bring Down Walls and Build Connections

By Katy Alexander

The first thing I encounter in this article is the unfamiliar phrase “Chicana Feminist.” I know from my Spanish classes that the word chica is Spanish for girl, but what does the -ana in chicana mean? A quick ctrl+c and crtl+v into the search bar reveals that Chicana Feminism is a subsection of feminism heralded by Mexican American women. The movement focuses primarily on “a perspective of being multiracial and multi-ethnic” (Alexander). In the article “Writing Poetry About Borderlands to Bring Down Walls and Build Connections” by Katy Alexander, she details how poetry, like Gloria Anzaldua’s poem “To live in the Borderlands means you” can be used in the classroom. Alexander instructs students to identify the “borderlands” of their lives, where they are split between two places.  

One quote that I found interesting is when Alexander explores how it is okay for student to be unsure of the meaning of a text, stating: “Maybe I’m not supposed to say this as a teacher, but I think it’s OK if students read a text and don’t really ‘get’ all of it. I think it’s OK if they still don’t ‘get’ all of it even after they’ve worked with it several times, as long as they get some of it, as long as they have some footholds, places to grab on to.” This is a tricky subject because if a student reads a text and does not comprehend it, then where are they going to get that comprehension from? Will they read a summary that someone else wrote online and regurgitate it as their own? Or will I tell them what to think so that they will mindlessly repeat my interpretation as fact without questioning me because I am the teacher?

The incorporation of poetry in the manner that Alexander presents it is an extremely Critical, antiractist, approach to teaching. In this approach, students explore their personal backgrounds and various identities in order to create a poem that is shared with the class. By sharing this poem and reading multicultural poems with the class, students are building a community within the classroom and are helping to create an environment that is warm and welcoming. As alexander writes, the goal of this is to “develop relationships, trust, and a community where they can know their multilingualism will be celebrated, not disrespected.”

Fieldwork: Into the thick of it


During the past two weeks I have finally begun my fieldwork placement at Central Falls High School. My time there begins about a ¼ mile away from the school, as there is no parking available. I initially mistook this blessing for a curse because of all the snow and rain that has been afflicting our state lately. Once that passed, I began to look at my walk as a way to gain insight into the community. I notice that all the businesses have signs in Spanish and English indicating that there is a heavy Latino community nearby. There are no single-family homes near the school. Instead, the area is populated tenement houses and apartment buildings.

Only 10.6% of CFHS students are proficient in SAT-ELA 


I tried to come into the school without a strong bias, so I avoided looking into Central Fall High School’s stats. This past week I observed the students in 11th grade English class take a placement test on IXCEL, an online testing suite with modules in English and Math. The questions on the test dynamically change depending on student answers, so I thought it would be a great opportunity to walk around the class and see where students where at skill-level wise. For once, I was grateful for the mask I was wearing as it hid the look of shock on my face as I looked at the types of questions that students were receiving and how a majority answered incorrectly. Students where far below grade level. Some students just refused to take the test and just stared at their screen until they were timed out for inactivity. I worry about these students, because they are almost done with their high school career despite being so far below grade level.

Saturday, February 26, 2022

Post 6: Chapter 1, Christensen Interview

 

                                              Surfing through the textbook on blog at a time....

Christensen, Teaching for Joy and Justice Chapter 1

Poetry is a thing that is usually taught as a single unit once during the year as either a steppingstone to writing longer narratives or analyzing larger texts. Christensen posits a different approach in her book, Teaching for Joy and Justice, where she claims that poetry is the key to unlock the full potential of students. According to Christensen, “Poetry levels the writing playing field. […] Many of my students who wrestle with essays write amazing poetry” (14). Christensen attributes her students’ knack for poetry due to their exposure to the similarities between it and hip hop. In that sense, teaching poetry in the classroom is a Critical approach to teaching as it incorporates students’ lived experiences into the curriculum. The power of poetry, Christensen states, allows us to “reclaim any part of our lives that society has degraded, humiliated, or shamed” (15). This approach to poetry is definitely a Critical one because in addition to incorporating relevant culture in the curriculum, Christensen is teaching students how to think in ways society has negatively affected their lives and “reclaim” it. This is where I stop and wonder about the word “reclaim.” To reclaim something would be to take back or find something that I lost. So, what have students lost? What has society taken away from them?

                                                      Poems are not always comfy and cozy

The word “reclaimed” hangs on to me. I think that “reclaiming” poetry may not be right for the classroom because of the intense personal focus that this poetry may have for students. A poem that Christensen shares later in the chapter titled “Dear Linda” illustrates this point. At this point in the chapter, the author of the book models an “advice poem” for the reader where she offers advice to herself from the perspective of her mother: “I’m sorry for the nights I left you alone/ after your father died/ I’m sorry for the solitary dinners / you ate those nights I chose a man over you “(35).  A deeply personal approach like this to learning, I feel, is too much and a line has been crossed.

 


Welcome to the family!

“The Power of Teaching Poetry” featuring RenĂ©e Watson and Linda Christensen

In this interview between Renee Watson and Linda Christensen, the pair discuss poetry’s place in the classroom and the power it has for students, as well as ways to encourage students through writing. In one part of the interview, Watson says, “If you tell me that I’m really good at metaphor, then I want to keep using metaphors in my work.” By telling students what they are doing well in their writing, teachers can expect for students to improve that specific skill even further. Ideally, this process should be done via “read alouds” because it creates bonds between students and the teacher which allows students to push themselves academically. The pair also discuss how, through building community in the classroom, students are more likely to take big emotional risks. Watson, in response to Christensen’s statement about emotional risks, states: “I want them to trust me so that when we go to something that might be a little more painful, or we take a heavier risk, we’ve already established a relationship with each other.” By allowing students space for discussing emotionally charged topics, the dynamic duo is invoking a Critical viewpoint of not just education, but the world at large. Watson declares that “being a social justice educator is being human in the classroom.” Being Critical does not just involve the main tenants of Social Justice, it can call for small personal moments in the classroom that call for reflection through poetry.

Thursday, February 17, 2022

Post 5 Joy, Testing, and Common Core

Chapter 5 Teaching for Joy and Justice, Linda Christensen

In this chapter of Christensen’s teaching book, she details how language can be a powerful tool in society and how those who are part of the dominant group can wield that power to the detriment of others. At the beginning of the chapter, Christensen discusses how, historically, indigenous peoples have the shared problem of being forced to enroll in an education system where it is the job of the teacher “to ‘whitewash’ students of color or students who are linguistically diverse” (Christensen 209). The role that schools play in the erosion of minority languages is very important to the author. Christensen notes that “schools continue to perpetuate the myths of inferiority or invisibility of some languages” (209). I think this is interesting; teaching students about the roles that schools play in the whitewashing/assimilation of its students. Furthermore, the study of language oppression is a Critical one because it shows how students can speak and write in ways that they are able to understand systems of oppression. 

However, I am unsure of a couple connections. First is what exactly skills are students supposed to gain from this. The common core emphasizes skill-based learning. Sure, students will be creating poetry and doing presentations, but why is learning about the destruction of languages important? What are students expected to do with this knowledge once they learn about it? The problem has been identified, but what is the solution? What comes next?

Racial Justice Is Not a Choice, Wayne Au



In the article “Racial Justice Is Not a Choice” Wayne Au argues that high-stakes testing goes hand in hand with white supremacy, writing: “It is critical we understand that high-stakes standardized tests do not serve students of color. They support white supremacy” (243). Clearly, as the five separate quotes that preface this article read, it has to do with the achievement gap. Au notes that there are wider societal factors at play, stating: “Test scores correlate most strongly with family income […] all factors that are measures of wealth that exist outside of schools” (244). This quote left me concerned because Au makes it seem that no matter what a teacher does, the only way that a student can do well on these standardized tests is if they were fortunate to be born into the “right” social class. If there is nothing that a teacher can do to help students succeed, then what’s the point in even having children come to school? Should we screen children while they are young and only take the “smart” ones into the education system, because “no amount of school instruction will ever make them intelligent voters or capable citizens” (244)? It’s concerning about whether intelligence is set or is able to be grown. I’m of the opinion that it can be grown.

There are many aspects to intelligence that can’t be seen in a standardized test, and this is where Muhammed’s concept of Criticality comes into play. Au agrees and posits that restorative and transformative assessment should take the place of standardized tests. Restorative assessment takes a holistic approach through “processed-based portfolios” that give a complete picture of student growth and achievement. Transformative assessment involves students getting active in the community to fight for social causes.

“Martin Luther King Jr. and the Common Core,” Daniel E. Ferguson


In this article the author, Ferguson, claims that the common core state standards do not allow any room for student interpretation. Ferguson uses excerpts from a video by David Coleman (the creator of common core) where he shows the optimal way to teach a ‘close reading’ of ‘Letter from Birmingham Jail.’” Judging by use of quotes of around the word “close reading,” it’s clear that Ferguson does not agree with Coleman’s definition of a close reading. Ferguson goes on to write how Coleman “asserts that reading instruction has overemphasized personal connections to texts at the expense of understanding the author’s meaning, assuming the two are diametrically opposed”. From reading this, I conclude that the common core state standards are not, in Muhammad’s definition of the word, Critical at all. This is because the CCSS ignores influences from outside of the text. This includes student connections, thoughts, and feelings to the text that may help them make sense of it on a personal level. Ferguson argues that obstructing these connections “is an act of oppression.” My question is when does a teacher know when it is time to move beyond the CCSS and start making personal connections to the text? Are students ever ready to move beyond the text or should they always be making personal connections in conjunction with a CCSS close reading?

Post 11: Christensen Chapter 3

  Teaching for Joy Teaching for Justice This week’s reading was from chapter 3 of  Teaching for Joy and Justice by Linda Christensen. In thi...