Teaching for Joy Teaching for Justice
This week’s reading was from chapter 3 of Teaching for Joy and Justice by Linda Christensen. In this
chapter, Christensen details various ways to make, what her students call, a ‘fire’
essay. This kind of essay is one where the students are highly self-motivated
to continuously draft and revise a piece of writing. Although it is not
possible to make every writing assignment ‘fire,’ appropriately preparing students
to tackle essay writing will improve their writing skills and turn them into ‘fire’
writers. However, the preparation that Christensen suggests is not the teaching
of the traditional 5 paragraph essay. Instead, Christen tells readers that preparation
for the “essay starts on the first day of any curriculum project” (121). This
is done through various techniques in which students retrieve and collect “information
from reading, media, and discussions” (121). Enriching a unit with a collection
of materials that students can go back to for future reference on their essays
is an incredibly smart way to teach essay writing. This method also saves a lot
of time in the classroom, because students already did a sizable portion of the
evidence finding as they read.
This is what happened when I read one of my blogs out loud
For the most part, Christensen covers the same ground as the classical five paragraph essay that I am familiar with from my time in the public school system. I enjoy that she takes a Critical approach to analytical writing when she states: “’Look, you can use incidents from your own life as evidence as well. If you had experiences with language that this unit tapped into, put those in the paper’” (124). By allowing students to incorporate a piece of oneself in their paper, Christensen sets the stage for them to examine ways in which their power, class, or race could be related to the unit or curriculum. I think that this is a great way to incorporate culturally responsive pedagogical practices into a writing style that is traditionally very formal and academic.
However, I did not find myself agreeing
with some of the advice present in the chapter. Namely the advice that “the thesis
statement […] can be stated explicitly or implicitly” (125). In writing an
essay, I am of the opinion that the thesis statement should always be
explicitly stated at the end of the first paragraph especially if it is an
analysis essay. One reason being that, as a reader of a student’s work, I would
assume that no thesis was written. The other reason being that a reader may
misinterpret an implicit thesis into meaning something that was not intended by
the author in way that may be unintentionally positive or negative.
In my placement at Central Falls High
School, I have yet to see any essay writing as of now. However, what I have
seen are retrieval and collection strategies on display in one English class.
This particular class is reading the book Born a Crime by Trevor Noah.
Every day when class starts, the teacher will have a few short response prompts
on the board that students have to answer either in class or for homework. This
serves two purposes. First, it shows the teacher that students are engaging
with the book. Second, the completion of these prompts will prove to be a
useful resource in the future as they will be writing an essay about the book
all on their own with no prompt from the teacher. This is a great real-life
example of one of Christensen’s strategies being used.