Surfing through the textbook on blog at a time....
Christensen,
Teaching for Joy and Justice Chapter 1
Poetry is a thing that is usually taught as a single unit once during the year as either a steppingstone to writing longer narratives or analyzing larger texts. Christensen posits a different approach in her book, Teaching for Joy and Justice, where she claims that poetry is the key to unlock the full potential of students. According to Christensen, “Poetry levels the writing playing field. […] Many of my students who wrestle with essays write amazing poetry” (14). Christensen attributes her students’ knack for poetry due to their exposure to the similarities between it and hip hop. In that sense, teaching poetry in the classroom is a Critical approach to teaching as it incorporates students’ lived experiences into the curriculum. The power of poetry, Christensen states, allows us to “reclaim any part of our lives that society has degraded, humiliated, or shamed” (15). This approach to poetry is definitely a Critical one because in addition to incorporating relevant culture in the curriculum, Christensen is teaching students how to think in ways society has negatively affected their lives and “reclaim” it. This is where I stop and wonder about the word “reclaim.” To reclaim something would be to take back or find something that I lost. So, what have students lost? What has society taken away from them?
Poems are not always comfy and cozy
The word “reclaimed”
hangs on to me. I think that “reclaiming” poetry may not be right for the
classroom because of the intense personal focus that this poetry may have for students.
A poem that Christensen shares later in the chapter titled “Dear Linda”
illustrates this point. At this point in the chapter, the author of the book
models an “advice poem” for the reader where she offers advice to herself from
the perspective of her mother: “I’m sorry for the nights I left you alone/
after your father died/ I’m sorry for the solitary dinners / you ate those
nights I chose a man over you “(35). A
deeply personal approach like this to learning, I feel, is too much and a line
has been crossed.
“The Power
of Teaching Poetry” featuring Renée Watson and Linda Christensen
In this interview
between Renee Watson and Linda Christensen, the pair discuss poetry’s place in
the classroom and the power it has for students, as well as ways to encourage
students through writing. In one part of the interview, Watson says, “If you
tell me that I’m really good at metaphor, then I want to keep using metaphors
in my work.” By telling students what they are doing well in their writing,
teachers can expect for students to improve that specific skill even further.
Ideally, this process should be done via “read alouds” because it creates bonds
between students and the teacher which allows students to push themselves
academically. The pair also discuss how, through building community in the
classroom, students are more likely to take big emotional risks. Watson, in
response to Christensen’s statement about emotional risks, states: “I want them
to trust me so that when we go to something that might be a little more
painful, or we take a heavier risk, we’ve already established a relationship
with each other.” By allowing students space for discussing emotionally charged
topics, the dynamic duo is invoking a Critical viewpoint of not just
education, but the world at large. Watson declares that “being a social justice
educator is being human in the classroom.” Being Critical does not just involve
the main tenants of Social Justice, it can call for small personal moments in
the classroom that call for reflection through poetry.