Saturday, February 26, 2022

Post 6: Chapter 1, Christensen Interview

 

                                              Surfing through the textbook on blog at a time....

Christensen, Teaching for Joy and Justice Chapter 1

Poetry is a thing that is usually taught as a single unit once during the year as either a steppingstone to writing longer narratives or analyzing larger texts. Christensen posits a different approach in her book, Teaching for Joy and Justice, where she claims that poetry is the key to unlock the full potential of students. According to Christensen, “Poetry levels the writing playing field. […] Many of my students who wrestle with essays write amazing poetry” (14). Christensen attributes her students’ knack for poetry due to their exposure to the similarities between it and hip hop. In that sense, teaching poetry in the classroom is a Critical approach to teaching as it incorporates students’ lived experiences into the curriculum. The power of poetry, Christensen states, allows us to “reclaim any part of our lives that society has degraded, humiliated, or shamed” (15). This approach to poetry is definitely a Critical one because in addition to incorporating relevant culture in the curriculum, Christensen is teaching students how to think in ways society has negatively affected their lives and “reclaim” it. This is where I stop and wonder about the word “reclaim.” To reclaim something would be to take back or find something that I lost. So, what have students lost? What has society taken away from them?

                                                      Poems are not always comfy and cozy

The word “reclaimed” hangs on to me. I think that “reclaiming” poetry may not be right for the classroom because of the intense personal focus that this poetry may have for students. A poem that Christensen shares later in the chapter titled “Dear Linda” illustrates this point. At this point in the chapter, the author of the book models an “advice poem” for the reader where she offers advice to herself from the perspective of her mother: “I’m sorry for the nights I left you alone/ after your father died/ I’m sorry for the solitary dinners / you ate those nights I chose a man over you “(35).  A deeply personal approach like this to learning, I feel, is too much and a line has been crossed.

 


Welcome to the family!

“The Power of Teaching Poetry” featuring Renée Watson and Linda Christensen

In this interview between Renee Watson and Linda Christensen, the pair discuss poetry’s place in the classroom and the power it has for students, as well as ways to encourage students through writing. In one part of the interview, Watson says, “If you tell me that I’m really good at metaphor, then I want to keep using metaphors in my work.” By telling students what they are doing well in their writing, teachers can expect for students to improve that specific skill even further. Ideally, this process should be done via “read alouds” because it creates bonds between students and the teacher which allows students to push themselves academically. The pair also discuss how, through building community in the classroom, students are more likely to take big emotional risks. Watson, in response to Christensen’s statement about emotional risks, states: “I want them to trust me so that when we go to something that might be a little more painful, or we take a heavier risk, we’ve already established a relationship with each other.” By allowing students space for discussing emotionally charged topics, the dynamic duo is invoking a Critical viewpoint of not just education, but the world at large. Watson declares that “being a social justice educator is being human in the classroom.” Being Critical does not just involve the main tenants of Social Justice, it can call for small personal moments in the classroom that call for reflection through poetry.

Thursday, February 17, 2022

Post 5 Joy, Testing, and Common Core

Chapter 5 Teaching for Joy and Justice, Linda Christensen

In this chapter of Christensen’s teaching book, she details how language can be a powerful tool in society and how those who are part of the dominant group can wield that power to the detriment of others. At the beginning of the chapter, Christensen discusses how, historically, indigenous peoples have the shared problem of being forced to enroll in an education system where it is the job of the teacher “to ‘whitewash’ students of color or students who are linguistically diverse” (Christensen 209). The role that schools play in the erosion of minority languages is very important to the author. Christensen notes that “schools continue to perpetuate the myths of inferiority or invisibility of some languages” (209). I think this is interesting; teaching students about the roles that schools play in the whitewashing/assimilation of its students. Furthermore, the study of language oppression is a Critical one because it shows how students can speak and write in ways that they are able to understand systems of oppression. 

However, I am unsure of a couple connections. First is what exactly skills are students supposed to gain from this. The common core emphasizes skill-based learning. Sure, students will be creating poetry and doing presentations, but why is learning about the destruction of languages important? What are students expected to do with this knowledge once they learn about it? The problem has been identified, but what is the solution? What comes next?

Racial Justice Is Not a Choice, Wayne Au



In the article “Racial Justice Is Not a Choice” Wayne Au argues that high-stakes testing goes hand in hand with white supremacy, writing: “It is critical we understand that high-stakes standardized tests do not serve students of color. They support white supremacy” (243). Clearly, as the five separate quotes that preface this article read, it has to do with the achievement gap. Au notes that there are wider societal factors at play, stating: “Test scores correlate most strongly with family income […] all factors that are measures of wealth that exist outside of schools” (244). This quote left me concerned because Au makes it seem that no matter what a teacher does, the only way that a student can do well on these standardized tests is if they were fortunate to be born into the “right” social class. If there is nothing that a teacher can do to help students succeed, then what’s the point in even having children come to school? Should we screen children while they are young and only take the “smart” ones into the education system, because “no amount of school instruction will ever make them intelligent voters or capable citizens” (244)? It’s concerning about whether intelligence is set or is able to be grown. I’m of the opinion that it can be grown.

There are many aspects to intelligence that can’t be seen in a standardized test, and this is where Muhammed’s concept of Criticality comes into play. Au agrees and posits that restorative and transformative assessment should take the place of standardized tests. Restorative assessment takes a holistic approach through “processed-based portfolios” that give a complete picture of student growth and achievement. Transformative assessment involves students getting active in the community to fight for social causes.

“Martin Luther King Jr. and the Common Core,” Daniel E. Ferguson


In this article the author, Ferguson, claims that the common core state standards do not allow any room for student interpretation. Ferguson uses excerpts from a video by David Coleman (the creator of common core) where he shows the optimal way to teach a ‘close reading’ of ‘Letter from Birmingham Jail.’” Judging by use of quotes of around the word “close reading,” it’s clear that Ferguson does not agree with Coleman’s definition of a close reading. Ferguson goes on to write how Coleman “asserts that reading instruction has overemphasized personal connections to texts at the expense of understanding the author’s meaning, assuming the two are diametrically opposed”. From reading this, I conclude that the common core state standards are not, in Muhammad’s definition of the word, Critical at all. This is because the CCSS ignores influences from outside of the text. This includes student connections, thoughts, and feelings to the text that may help them make sense of it on a personal level. Ferguson argues that obstructing these connections “is an act of oppression.” My question is when does a teacher know when it is time to move beyond the CCSS and start making personal connections to the text? Are students ever ready to move beyond the text or should they always be making personal connections in conjunction with a CCSS close reading?

Thursday, February 10, 2022

Post 4: Christensen ch.6, Elbow and B. Sharing and Responding, Fieldwork

 

Christensen, Chapter 6




This week’s texts focused on providing feedback to students. Chapter 6 of Teaching for Joy and Justice focuses on Christensen’s interesting approach to grading which comes in the form of an analytic approach to grading. Instead filling pages with red ink, Christensen deep dives into her “students’ papers and categorize[s] each student’s errors, looking for patterns” (265). By doing this Christensen is providing a running record of things that her students can work on. I think that is the key takeaway of her grading mantra. Students should have a growth mindset when it comes to writing. I think that Christensen best captures this frame of thinking when she writes: “I still remember the day when in a frenzy of doing my job right, I correct every error on Jerald’s budding paper and witnessed his transformation from eager to dejected student” (265).  A dejected student is on who does not want to improve because all the intrinsic value that writing had for him/her is gone because of the dreaded red pen. Whenever I received corrections on something that I completed for school I would feel like Bart Simpson and cover my eyes when I got back the paper. I hated seeing tons of corrections on my papers. I felt pretty similar to the "dejected student" that Christensen uses in her example. 

This stance on language correction is also a social justice/Critically focused one as Christensen makes it a point to say that language is a social construct. Specifically mentioning that subgenres of English, like AAVE (Ebonics/African American English Vernacular), are appropriate for one setting while inappropriate in another (like formal English). By taking such a firm anti-racist approach to grading students, Christensen is creating a culturally inclusive space in her classroom.

 

Elbow & Belanoff, Pages 7-16 Sharing and Responding



In this excerpt by Elbow and Belanoff titled “Summary of Kinds of Responses,” the pair covers similar ground to what Christensen covered about providing feedback to students. However, Elbow and Belanoff are more concerned with providing feedback through peer and self-editing than with grades and grammar use. They are instead focused on the ideas and feelings that text presents to the reader.  The duo list 11 ways that writers can provide useful feedback to each other. I do prefer feedback to corrections because it lets me, as a student, know why the teacher thinks this way about a particular line. In other words, I have a clearer idea of where to go when I have written feedback. I think that's the key phrase: "where to go." Because of the feedback I know that I can make my writing better and have someplace to take it. 

My favorite of which is number 9: “Believing and Doubting” (10). I try to do this to my writing as much as possible (mostly with the doubting portion). I usually do this by letting whatever I wrote sit for a while before coming back to read it so I can put some distance between myself and the words on the page. I then try to tear into my writing to find the weak spots. Conversely, I find it pretty much useless to “believe” myself because of course I’m going to believe myself—I wrote it! So, if you have something nice to say about my writing, you better not say it to my face. Elbow and Belanoff write that believing is about having a reader “believe everything I have written, even if you disagree or find it crazy” (10). My question about this is what purpose does “believing” serve? I think that would result in a yes-man mentality and create an editor who is afraid to push back against the writer. But as a reader of student writing, I feel that I may come across as too harsh. I also have trouble connecting this to Muhammed’s definition of Criticality. I do not see explicit social justice or anti-racist practices in Elbow and Belanoff’s feedback protocols.


Fieldwork



I am excited to begin my fieldwork in a public school. This will be the second time that I am entering a classroom and maybe even the first time I even finish a placement! If that didn’t sound so concerning, I would be happier. I don’t know what to expect from this placement. My very first placement was over two years ago, and the children were incredibly rowdy and precocious to say the least. It was my first semester of SEE and I was placed in a 3rd grade MLL classroom. I actually had no idea that the students were MLLs until I was asked to help some students with their writing assignments. I felt that I was very unprepared for that placement.  I anticipate that I will be more prepared for this placement because of all the coursework and VR mission training that I have done. Now it’s time for the real thing.

Wednesday, February 2, 2022

Post 3 Teaching Emergent Bilinguals

 

#137. Three Essential Roles of Monolingual Teachers by Tan Huynh



Bilingualism is a desired skill in an increasingly globalist economy. Bilingualism should be encouraged in schools as it adds another tool for students to make use of outside of the classroom. Tan Huynh began his article arguing that multilingual teachers are more valuable than monolingual teachers, stating, “If I had a child enrolled in this school, I would hope they are placed in classrooms with a multilingual teacher.” Without the mastery of another language under their belt, monolingual teachers can’t offer the same benefits to students those multilingual teachers do, like “heightened cognitive skills that come from the demands of manipulating multiple languages” (Huynh). However, monolingual teachers can be an asset “in ensuring that their students become more multilingual, multiliterate, and multicultural.” This relates to Muhammed’s concept of Criticality in that by having monolingual teachers incorporate cultural elements from non-white cultures students are learning the merits of cultures that are marginalized.

Being an advocate for multilingual learners sounds like a good thing. Students will be learning a desired skill that will help them in life. However, I am having trouble imagining an English classroom that, according to Huynh, allows for “students to also be multiliterate in their home language and not just English.” There could be a variety of different languages spoken by students at home, so is it expected that a teacher has mastery of these languages and teach them in the classroom? How should teachers support mastery in two different languages if the teacher only speaks one language?

NCTE Position Paper on the Role of English Teachers in Educating English Language Learners (ELLs) From NCTE

 


The main takeaway I had from this paper was the surprising amount of English Language Learners there are in the American school system. According to NCTE “In 2015, 9.5 percent (4.8 million students) of all public school students nationwide were classified as ELLs.” There is a very real need for appropriate instruction of ELL students that many teachers are not prepared for. This incredibly dense paper from NCTE discusses ways English teachers can support ELL’s in the classroom. As I read, I did not come across any notions of Muhammed’s Criticality. Most of the guidelines were somewhat open ended and allowed for some instructional freedom. Because of the choice being able to include elements of Criticality in the instruction, one could argue that this is Critical/culturally responsive teaching. However, I think that for this to be considered Critical by Muhammed, the suggestions in the paper would have to tell teachers to “read diverse texts that reflect students’ cultural backgrounds” instead of “Utilizing mentor texts in both English and students’ home languages” (NCTE). The latter does not mention that the text requires any sort of relevancy to the student. One question that I have is what is causing the huge increase in ELL students in recent years compared to previous years?

 

Understanding Translanguaging in US Literacy Classrooms by Kate Seltzer and Cati V. de los Ríos



    Translanguaging is the practice of fluidly moving between one language and another. A common example of translanguaging could be found when students use common nouns like grandma and mother in their home language when speaking English. One interesting takeaway that I got from this article was that ELL students should not be compared to monolingual English speakers. According to Seltzer and Rios, “Rather than compare bi-/multilingual students to their 'monolingual' English-speaking counterparts, which often results in deficit perceptions of their language and literacy practices, a translanguaging lens enables educators to perceive students differently” (4). Initially, I found this counterintuitive. Why wouldn’t I compare upcoming ELL’s to their native counterparts to gauge their proficiency in English? The article authors argue that this line of thinking is flawed because learning English (or any language, really) is not a linear process. Pedagogical techniques like translanguaging allows for a non-linear approach to learning a second language.

This text matches Muhammad’s concept of Criticality. By incorporating practices like translanguaging, the authors of this article aim to “disrupt the hierarchies that have delegitimized the language practices of those who are minoritized” (Vogel & García, p. 1). I think that this shows that students are not the only ones who benefit from looking at the world through a Critical lens. Since translanguaging practices are done by the teacher, they are the ones who will be thinking in ways in which power, social class, and language come together. One question I have is how does this come together in the end? In other words, how do I move students from translanguaging to just English speaking? Should translanguaging be a permanent tool in a student’s repertoire?

Post 11: Christensen Chapter 3

  Teaching for Joy Teaching for Justice This week’s reading was from chapter 3 of  Teaching for Joy and Justice by Linda Christensen. In thi...